Tesla Claimed Cybertruck May Pull “Close to Infinite Mass” — What Does That Even Imply?


A number of days in the past, I noticed that automotive media shops discovered one thing actually terrible on Tesla’s Cybertruck web page. Most producers offer you a tow ranking and use that of their promoting claims, however Tesla went the additional Cybermile and claimed that its car can pull “close to infinite mass.” I checked for myself, and never solely is that this hilarious declare one thing they’re actually making, however it’s nonetheless dwell on the location as of this writing.

To Be Honest …

To be totally honest to the Tesla group, they’re not the one folks to do loopy issues to promote a towing car, and this isn’t even the primary time they’ve finished it.

Let’s begin with the prototype F-150 Lightning’s towing stunt:

No person’s going to assert that the F-150 Lightning can pull a million-pound trailer, however should you put the million kilos on rails (which reduces rolling resistance) and solely want to tug it on stage floor at low speeds, there actually isn’t any cause the Lightning couldn’t pull over 1,000,000 kilos. So, it’s true, however it’s not one thing you possibly can translate to real-world truck use until you occur to personal a railyard.

Whereas not 1,000,000 kilos, there’s additionally the time Toyota pulled a Area Shuttle with a Tundra:

You’ll discover that just like the F-150 prototype stunt, the Tundra has virtually zero weight on its tongue. The entire weight of the Endeavor is being held up by the axles beneath it, so the Tundra solely needed to construct up momentum and never bear the burden of the Area Shuttle in any respect.

Simply to place the icing on the cake, right here’s a Porsche SUV proving its value pulling an airliner:

Which is one thing Tesla has finished, too:

So, sure, automobiles of every kind can usually pull some critical mass round. With the low-end torque that’s prone to be obtainable on the Tesla Cybertruck, it’s going to be technically able to pulling fairly a little bit of mass round. To show this, there’ll most likely be a number of stunt pulls just like the above finished with the truck each by the corporate and by superfans who need to show one thing.

Stunt pulls don’t actually show something for real-world towing, however they do present that there’s a variety of energy and torque available. There are real-world towing assessments on the market, which are supposed to decide what a car can pull in real-world situations. However these loopy stunt pulls are simply an instance of a “drawbar pull.”

However Is It “Close to Infinite?”

As Jason Torchinsky at The Autopian mentions, there’s a approach to calculate drawbar pulls based mostly on the torque of the car. In case you select a towing goal with low rolling resistance, and use a variety of torque (one thing Cybertruck may have), the pulling capability (not towing, however pulling) must be within the tens of millions of kilos. So, sure, the numbers will probably be very massive (as soon as we have now them).

However the issue with “close to infinite” is that it’s a meaningless time period. It’s not simply obscure, however actually meaningless. Mathematically talking, one thing can both be infinite or not. If there’s too many to presumably ever depend since you’d by no means get to the top (as a result of there isn’t any finish), then it’s infinite. If it’s countable in any respect, even when it’s a extremely massive quantity, then it’s finite. In different phrases, one thing is both infinite or it’s not, sort of like somebody can both be pregnant or not pregnant. If an individual was “close to pregnant,” then they’re simply not.

Because the xkcd comedian factors out, this can be a widespread factor to see in promoting, although. Imprecise, meaningless, and anti-mathematical claims are, the truth is, quite common. One instance they offer is GEICO’s “save as much as 15% or extra” tagline. As a result of financial savings could be detrimental (i.e., not saving) and the quantity could be as much as 15, but in addition presumably extra, there’s an infinite variety of attainable financial savings outcomes. In different phrases, meaningless advertising and marketing hogwash.

I Wouldn’t Name It Fraudulent, Although

That having been stated, Elon Musk likes to make use of scientific or scientific sounding phrases to say “actually massive,” and he likes to throw sci-fi sounding phrases round to sound spectacular. “Order of magnitude” is a standard one to listen to from him, for instance. He describes factories as “cybernetic collectives,” and Twitter thusly:

I’m not making an attempt to name out Elon Musk as a fraud right here, although (so, please, no extra ready-fire-aim C&D letters, Elon). The purpose I need to make is that that is Elon Musk’s fashion. Generally it does border on sci-fi technobabble, however it often has some sort of actual that means behind it, even when considerably exaggerated. An order of magnitude often means so as to add a zero on the top, which makes the quantity lots greater. However, it may also be utilized in a lot the identical manner because the time period “exorbitant,” which doesn’t actually imply past orbit, however can imply “actually massive or costly.”

The time period “close to infinite” has no exact mathematical that means, however it does sound cool and scientific. It additionally sounds actually, actually massive. It’s additionally laborious to name it out as false promoting as a result of it doesn’t really specify a testable declare (which makes it decidedly unscientific). It’s Musk’s fashion.

However, I wouldn’t go so far as to name this fraud, as a result of it isn’t actually trying to deceive folks. No person thinks {that a} Cybertruck may pull Jupiter across the photo voltaic system (even should you may by some means hook a tow rope as much as a ball of fuel). No person thinks Cybertruck will probably be Chuck Norris’s truck, and transfer the Earth as a substitute of transferring alongside the Earth.

And actually, Chuck Norris Info are most likely an effective way to know this declare. No person actually thinks Chuck counted to infinity twice. No person actually thinks {that a} cobra as soon as bit him and that after 5 excruciating days of ache, the cobra died. No person actually believes that he could make onions cry. However, as a result of he was in some actually unrealistic Hollywood motion movies, it’s a cultural reference that everybody understands, and we’re the insiders on the joke after we title his ridiculous feats the way in which that Starlord/Peter Quill tells aliens concerning the feats of Kevin Bacon and David Hasselhoff within the Guardians of the Galaxy sequence.

We all know that Elon Musk’s firms say loopy technobabble-sounding stuff as a result of that’s what Elon does. Nearly no one, whether or not a skeptic like me or the nuttiest superstan, actually believes that the Cybertruck will be capable of tow itself into the long run by approaching the infinite.

However, if it did, some fortunate (or very unfortunate) Cybertruck proprietor would get to actually say the final line from Planet of the Apes and rattling us all to hell.

Featured picture by Tesla.




Admire CleanTechnica’s originality and cleantech information protection? Contemplate changing into a CleanTechnica Member, Supporter, Technician, or Ambassador — or a patron on Patreon.


Do not need to miss a cleantech story? Join each day information updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or observe us on Google Information!


Have a tip for CleanTechnica, need to promote, or need to recommend a visitor for our CleanTech Discuss podcast? Contact us right here.



Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.