I don’t assume I have to introduce readers to Elon Musk’s on-line antics. I additionally in all probability don’t want to elucidate that it’s critically hurting Tesla’s model, its inventory worth, and its future. Zach already did a radical job of explaining this and displaying the receipts, so I gained’t try this once more. As a substitute, I need to strategy this from a extra optimistic angle.
In brief, I’m glad that Elon’s psychological issues and give attention to right-wing politics occurred in 2020–2022 and never, say, 2010–2012 or 2016–2018. Why? As a result of EVs have develop into sufficient of a drive, and have gained adequate momentum, to succeed with or with out Elon Musk — and even Tesla now.
The Newest Problematic Tweeting Episode
Earlier than I clarify why I’m nonetheless very optimistic about clear know-how and EVs going ahead, I do need to rapidly present why persons are beginning to fear. Zach’s piece does a way more thorough job of this, however I believe the elemental drawback right here could be defined in only a few embedded tweets that ought to horrify anybody who’s acquired some huge cash invested.
My pronouns are Prosecute/Fauci
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) December 11, 2022
In simply 5 phrases, he managed to kick the LGBT hornet’s nest, name for the imprisonment of a extremely achieved and altruistic public determine, and categorical assist for an advanced set of conspiracy theories across the origins and dealing with of the coronavirus pandemic. That’s a variety of heavy lifting for only a few phrases.
However, this isn’t nearly United States politics and “libs” hating on Elon. If you happen to’re aware of the accusations Republicans make towards Anthony Fauci, the largest accusation is that he labored with the Chinese language authorities to engineer the virus and make it worse. Even when this was true (most medical consultants say there’s inadequate proof of this), saying that Fauci did this places Elon Musk at odds with the autocratic Chinese language Communist Occasion, whose good graces he depends on to do enterprise in China.
As massive of a deal because the Shanghai plant and different Chinese language operations are to Tesla, it is a fairly harmful factor for Elon to maintain pushing. I’m not within the behavior (and lack the experience) of giving folks monetary and funding recommendation, however I’d be very apprehensive proper now if I owned any Tesla inventory. He’s skating on some skinny ice with the Chinese language authorities.
And he appears to be doubling down on each side of that Fauci tweet:
I strongly disagree. Forcing your pronouns upon others after they didn’t ask, and implicitly ostracizing those that don’t, is neither good nor form to anybody.
As for Fauci, he lied to Congress and funded gain-of-function analysis that killed thousands and thousands of individuals. Not superior imo.
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) December 12, 2022
Whereas most individuals don’t contemplate a CEO (or Technoking, or no matter Elon’s figuring out as lately) and his political opinions when buying a automotive, it’s producing sufficient unhealthy emotions that persons are beginning to shift their EV shopping for to different corporations. Listed here are a few well-known individuals who did simply that:
Me too. I simply purchased a good looking @chevrolet BOLT EUV yesterday, having cancelled my @Tesla buy. Individuals’s phrases and actions matter. https://t.co/cQJIIlavJN
— Robert Picardo (@RobertPicardo) December 12, 2022
The EUV is a superb choose at an amazing worth (I personal one myself), however I’d think about that seeing notable folks bail on Tesla as a result of they will’t stand Elon Musk isn’t going to be nice for the model.
I was happy with my Tesla. However now that @elonmusk far proper conspiracy idea spreader and bully of public well being authorities I’m embarrassed to be seen as endorsing him. I additionally offered my Tesla shares.
— Martin Varsavsky 🇺🇦 (@martinvars) December 13, 2022
I used to be a HUGE Tesla fan, we now have two Teslas. However @elonmusk has a private model and his conduct on Twitter is hurting his model and that of Tesla. I do not really feel the identical driving a Tesla anymore.
— Martin Varsavsky 🇺🇦 (@martinvars) December 13, 2022
It’s unhappy to see @elonmusk at Twitter. I’ve been a fan for therefore lengthy. I met him twice and thought the most effective of him. Tesla is the primary automotive I fell in love with. Starlink is pure genius, so resilient in case of fibre optic assault. However on Twitter he’s the proprietor and a bully.
— Martin Varsavsky 🇺🇦 (@martinvars) December 13, 2022
Why I’m Nonetheless Optimistic About EVs, Cleantech, and Tesla Itself
Once I noticed that Tesla was being damage by Elon Musk’s conduct, I’ve to confess that I used to be a bit of bit like Jeremy Clarkson within the brief video clip embedded above. When confronted with some unhealthy information, he was like, “Oh NO! Anyway…”
I’m feeling that means about Tesla in 2022 as a result of it’s not the middle of the EV universe that it as soon as was. If Tesla had gone down in flames in 2010, the business wouldn’t have moved within the path it did, as a result of there would have been no actual strain. Whilst late as 2016–2017, automobiles just like the Mannequin S, Mannequin X, and Nissan LEAF have been area of interest automobiles and most producers didn’t have any severe EV efforts going. If the strain had dropped off in these days, most automakers would have in all probability backed out of the EV world with a wry smile and saved making financial institution on ICE automobiles.
However in the present day, issues have moved fairly a bit. EVs can be found at costs nicely under the typical price of a brand new automotive in the present day (with the Chevy Bolt EV being the most cost effective pre-incentive instance). Used EVs can be found within the teenagers. So, principally, each phase however the “shitbox” or “beater” used segments have an honest EV. (Even then, closely degraded LEAFs make an OK short-range “shitbox” for some folks.)
Non-Tesla charging infrastructure could be very usable in comparison with the place it was even in 2019, and the infrastructure invoice goes to massively broaden CCS charging. Tax incentives are coming again for all manufacturers, and even might be obtainable as a point-of-sale rebate for collaborating sellers. There may also be US rebates and credit for used EVs for the primary time.
So, I believe it’s fairly protected to say that even when Tesla fully imploded, the remainder of the EV business isn’t going anyplace. That cat’s out of the bag, and it isn’t going again in.
I’d additionally argue that the entire destruction of Tesla can be extraordinarily unlikely. The inventory and the gross sales might take a significant massacre if Elon Musk retains performing like he lives in a right-wing model of Wait However Why’s “Political Disney World,” the place fantasy and what feels good trumps actuality, and also you don’t have to know the details. His flamboyant methods might, at worst, get the corporate kicked out of China, and we’d watch the Shanghai plant begin churning out Tesla automobiles with out Musk’s permission.
Even when issues acquired that unhealthy (and I don’t assume that’s terribly seemingly), I don’t assume Tesla goes to die. It’s a giant firm, and it survives on the exhausting, exhausting work and abilities of tens of 1000’s of individuals. Musk might do some severe injury, however the automobiles are first rate automobiles and so they have a really first rate charging community (the most effective in some international locations). The corporate is now an enormous business participant, not a precarious upstart. It could in all probability take injury far past that which Elon Musk is able to to destroy Tesla.
So, I don’t assume Tesla or the broader EV business is in mortal hazard. If Tesla disappeared, the remainder of the automotive business is already dedicated to EVs and might’t again out now. Tesla itself could possibly be critically damage by Musk, however it is rather unlikely to go away and by no means get better. There’s merely an excessive amount of potential worth there for it to not be put underneath new administration if issues acquired that unhealthy. There could possibly be some short-term issues, however in the long term Tesla will very seemingly nonetheless exist and thrive.
For these causes, I’m nonetheless a cleantech optimist.
Featured picture by Tesla and CleanTechnica.
Full our 2022 CleanTechnica reader survey for an opportunity to win an electrical bike.
Recognize CleanTechnica’s originality and cleantech information protection? Contemplate changing into a CleanTechnica Member, Supporter, Technician, or Ambassador — or a patron on Patreon.
Do not need to miss a cleantech story? Join each day information updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or comply with us on Google Information!
Have a tip for CleanTechnica, need to promote, or need to recommend a visitor for our CleanTech Discuss podcast? Contact us right here.
