Counter-Economics: The Actual Motive Why Many On The Proper Concern Clear Applied sciences & Power Effectivity

Join each day information updates from CleanTechnica on electronic mail. Or comply with us on Google Information!

In one other article I wrote for the anniversary of the 9/11 assaults, I questioned the best way conservatives and Republicans shifted away from help for different fuels.

After the assaults, it grew to become clear once more that counting on the Center East for oil was a strategically dangerous factor. EVs and hybrids had been a part of this dialogue, however different choices like CNG, propane, ethanol, and simply making autos extra environment friendly had been all a part of the dialogue. Fuel stations now principally promote 10% ethanol, and for some time many autos had been bought with the power to run on 85% ethanol, with badges on the again of vehicles and SUVs proudly displaying their capability to run on E85, or flex gas.

There have been additionally grander plans to maneuver the U.S. away from counting on oil a lot, with most likely probably the most well-publicized instance being the Pickens Plan, full with TV commercials to put it on the market. His concept was mainly to maneuver many autos to pure fuel after which energy as many different issues as doable with wind and photo voltaic, thus decreasing or eliminating oil imports. That plan was by no means put into severe consideration by trade and authorities, but it surely’s value noting that we’re form of implementing a variant of it, as EVs are charged with electrical energy generated at pure fuel vegetation in lots of areas and this displaces oil consumption.

(Aspect notice: it’s nonetheless extra environmentally pleasant to burn easy methane molecules in an environment friendly combined-cycle fuel turbine than it’s to burn extra complicated fuel and diesel in comparatively low cost piston engines, so EVs are nonetheless means forward.)

However, what would possibly shock some youthful readers is that the Republican occasion as soon as absolutely supported EV tax credit. Hybrids exploded in recognition after 9/11, and there was a 2005 legislation (signed by President George W. Bush) that supplied tax credit for them. Later, the $7500 tax credit for EVs was additionally signed into legislation by Bush.

So, it’s fairly clear that mainstream Republicans used to sing a really completely different tune in terms of different fuels and EVs. I do know we have now many Republican readers right here who personal an EV and who’re most likely equally confused at what their occasion has turn into on this difficulty. As an alternative of supporting different fuels and EVs like they used to, they’re telling all kinds of lies about their environmental impacts (which is one thing they usually don’t care about). They’re blaming energy outages on them, regardless of loads of proof exhibiting different causes.

However, this nonetheless leaves us with the query of why they modified their thoughts on this. Once I wrote that 9/11 article, I puzzled on the finish whether or not it’s financial insecurity that’s inflicting this shift, with renewables getting the blame when an enormous photo voltaic farm will get arrange in a city and no locals make something from it. However, that solely explains the habits of particular person voters in some small cities, and never the widespread hatred of unpolluted applied sciences amongst conservative media personalities and politicians.

Following The Cash

One method to finding out this additional was to search for monetary hyperlinks. When one thing in politics and enterprise doesn’t appear to make a lot sense, you may often “comply with the cash” and determine why issues are the best way they’re.

In america, oil corporations overwhelmingly give cash to Republicans with the sum of money going to them spiking throughout the late 2000s. Conservative media retailers are additionally identified to obtain huge cash from oil and fracking corporations, so it ought to be no shock that they toe the road. However, together with advantages to grease corporations from the unfold of local weather change denial, anti-EV propaganda, and outright lies about energy outages comes different nasty issues, like anti-LGBT propaganda, help for Russia and different oligarchic or dictatorial regimes, and the lack of reproductive rights. All of that is now propped up by oil cash.

Overseas oil cash additionally finds its means into U.S. politics. For instance, Saudi Arabia’s dictatorship has been caught funding members/household of the Trump administration, spending “darkish cash” to elect Republicans, and a wide range of different affect operations. And, these are just some of those which have come to gentle. What number of extra affect operations, secret donations, and different corruption is occurring out of view?

The Provide-Aspect Of “Getting Cash Out Of Politics”

I do know the pure progressive response to those cash hyperlinks is that we have to “get cash out of politics.” This often comes within the type of requires marketing campaign finance limits, public marketing campaign cash, and different reforms that might hold oil corporations, international oil-funded governments, and different darkish influences out of politics.

However, that’s solely marketing campaign donations. Even when none of those entities may present cash to politicians, it might be a violation of the First Modification to ban media retailers, social media influencers, and others with nice energy over public opinion from taking promoting cash or donations from the oil trade. Plus, darkish cash, “items,” and different unlawful dealings would nonetheless proceed regardless of any legal guidelines towards them, and that legal exercise might be very troublesome to detect and eradicate. In any case, we will’t prohibit a billionaire from making buddies with a politician and taking him on holidays.

So, oil corporations and different moneyed entities aren’t afraid of marketing campaign finance reform.

However, there’s one thing that frightens all of them to the bones: not having the cash within the financial institution to deprave the nation with. If they begin making much less cash promoting fossil fuels, renting out costly actual property, and operating monopolies, they’ll begin to lose their capability to affect the federal government insurance policies that permit them to proceed to do what they do. The recipients of this soiled cash likewise worry shedding it, as a result of official political donations, promoting, and different types of help aren’t proud of the thought of getting their identify related to the worst conservative insurance policies.

This worry jogged my memory of the idea of “counter-economics” within the anarchist and libertarian political spheres. Going past the idea of voting along with your {dollars} and never supporting companies that interact in politics, counter-economics has the broader intention of crippling corrupt governments (which, to them not less than, is just about all governments) by eroding the help they obtain.

At worst, the idea consists of issues like tax evasion, drug smuggling, arms trafficking, and different unlawful issues circuitously tied to violence (they particularly exclude the “purple market,” or legal violence). However, the thought of counter-economics additionally consists of authorized issues, like reaching as a lot private independence as doable and decreasing one’s private want for the “providers” of governments and their corrupt company buddies.

It ought to be no shock that clear vitality has been part of counter-economics from the start. Governments don’t get a lower of the daylight that powers photo voltaic panels, and so they don’t get a lower of the wind that turns a turbine. Likewise, the massive corporations fueling and/or taking part within the corruption find yourself shedding their lower of the motion.

This makes clear vitality not solely a good suggestion for the atmosphere and the family finances, but in addition an essential type of civil disobedience and political resistance. That is much more true while you go off-grid and refuse to take part within the city/suburban actual property markets that enrich folks like Harlan Crow, who likes to provide Supreme Court docket Justice Clarence Thomas costly items and lavish holidays. The identical is true for individuals who refuse to commute pointlessly to workplace jobs, which has the double impact of burning fossil fuels and propping up city actual property tycoons.

So, you don’t must be an anarchist or a libertarian to understand the idea of counter-economics. Merely going photo voltaic, going off-grid, and refusing to take part in wasteful practices like commuting will help dry up the funding rent-seeking politicians and businessmen depend on to oppress us all.

Featured picture: a conveyable Shiftpod shelter and solar energy. Picture by Jennifer Sensiba.


Have a tip for CleanTechnica? Need to promote? Need to recommend a visitor for our CleanTech Discuss podcast? Contact us right here.

EV Obsession Each day!

I do not like paywalls. You do not like paywalls. Who likes paywalls? Right here at CleanTechnica, we carried out a restricted paywall for some time, but it surely at all times felt incorrect — and it was at all times powerful to resolve what we must always put behind there. In principle, your most unique and finest content material goes behind a paywall. However then fewer folks learn it!! So, we have determined to utterly nix paywalls right here at CleanTechnica. However…


Like different media corporations, we want reader help! If you happen to help us, please chip in a bit month-to-month to assist our group write, edit, and publish 15 cleantech tales a day!



Tesla Gross sales in 2023, 2024, and 2030



CleanTechnica makes use of affiliate hyperlinks. See our coverage right here.