A Ship Carrying Electrical Vehicles Is On Fireplace! We Should Run And Inform The King!!

In July, a ship known as the Fremantle Freeway was carrying 3,784 new automobiles throughout the Atlantic ocean on its approach to Singapore when it caught fireplace. 498 of the autos aboard have been electrical automobiles. Due to the wonders of the web, shortly after information in regards to the burning ship reached the eyes and ears of tens of millions of individuals, it turned recognized that a few of these automobiles have been battery-electric autos. In truth, an worker of the ship’s proprietor, Shoei Kisen Kaisha, was the primary to recommend the hearth was attributable to these EVs.

It wasn’t lengthy  — about 2.7 nanoseconds in accordance with calculations carried out by a crack crew of cyber sleuths at CleanTechnica — earlier than phrase unfold all through the recognized world that a number of of the 489 electrical automobiles was the wrongdoer. Since it’s well-known that electrical automobile batteries generally catch fireplace, it appeared protected to imagine that’s what occurred aboard the Fremantle Freeway.

Now we have all been handled to lurid tales within the press about how intense battery fires are. As movies of the smoke billowing from the stricken ship rocketed throughout the web, many speculated {that a} fireplace that large and intense have to be associated to the electrical automobiles on board. The headlines screamed and the speaking heads spoke with righteous indignation in regards to the scourge of electrical automobiles and the way packing them into the maintain of a ship was simply begging for a horrific incident.

Lo and behold, their prognostications had come true. Simply as predicted, now one other ship was on fireplace. When would individuals study to not ship electrical automobiles by sea? Oh, the horror! The information media went loopy with lurid tales of how electrical automobiles have been answerable for the hearth that killed one crew member and threatened the lives of 21 others who needed to be rescued by helicopters.

The final time a blaze occurred aboard a ship carrying electrical automobiles, the ship sank in 10,000 toes of water, making it unlikely the reason for that fireplace will ever be decided. At the moment, Joao Mendes Cabecas, the captain of the ship often called Facility Ace advised the press that lithium-ion batteries within the electrical automobiles on board helped stop the crew from extinguishing the blaze.

On this case, nevertheless, the hearth was extinguished finally and the disabled craft was towed to Eemshaven, a port in northeastern Netherlands, the place salvage operations have begun. Peter Berdowski is in control of the salvage operation, which is being undertaken by Royal Boskalis Westminster NV. After inspecting the broken ship, he advised the native press that between 900 and 1000 of the automobiles on board look like in good situation — together with all 498 electrical automobiles.

Berdowski advised Bloomberg the hearth in all probability began within the eighth deck of the 12-deck ship, as that’s the place the worst injury is. The electrical automobiles have been all on decks far beneath. Nonetheless, Berdowksi himself fanned the flames by saying “all specialists with any information on this matter agree that the transportation of electrical autos introduces extra dangers.”

Electrical Vehicles & Fires At Sea

Berdowski and the unnamed worker of the ship’s proprietor are complicated coincidence with causality. It’s like saying a visitors accident occurred shortly after a person sporting a fedora crossed the road on the identical location. Each statements are true. There was an accident and a person sporting a fedora did cross the road simply earlier than it occurred. However there is no such thing as a causal relationship between the 2.

One other instance is the person who walks round snapping his fingers all day. When he’s requested why he’s snapping his fingers, he says he’s doing it to maintain the elephants away. “However there are not any elephants wherever close to right here!” his inquisitor exclaims. “See?” the person says. “That simply proves snapping my fingers is working!”

Tales flood into CleanTechnica’s state-of-the-art communications heart all day daily about fires attributable to e-bike batteries. Make no mistake, these tales are actual and the injury they trigger will be horrific. We’d by no means make gentle of the tragedy a hearth of any variety is able to. Nevertheless, many e-bikes have solely a rudimentary battery administration system at greatest. In addition they are typically charged to 100% capability each time, which will increase the chance of battery fires.

Lastly, they’re topic to tampering by unskilled house owners or being charged with tools that’s far lower than state-of-the-art. The batteries in electrical automobiles typically have refined cooling and battery administration techniques designed to stop them from catching fireplace.

What Insurance coverage Firms Know

Insurance coverage corporations handle threat for a dwelling. With regards to understanding what actions are harmful and which aren’t, they’re those to show to for the straight skinny. The Pushed experiences that following the hearth aboard the Fremantle Freeway, the Worldwide Union of Marine Insurance coverage stated in an announcement, “So far, no fireplace onboard a roro or Pure Automotive and Truck Provider (PCTC) has been confirmed to have been attributable to a factory-new EV. IUMI understands that the transportation of EVs raises sure dangers which might be completely different to these concerned in carrying inside combustion engine autos however analysis means that the dangers aren’t heightened or extra harmful.“

Information from the Swedish Civil Contingencies Company (MSB) exhibits EVs are 20 instances much less prone to catch fireplace than gasoline and diesel automobiles. In 2022, there have been 23 fires within the nation’s fleet of 611,000 electrical automobiles, for an incidence fee of 0.004%. Over the identical interval, 3,400 fires have been reported in Sweden’s 4.4 million petrol and diesel automobiles for an incidence fee of 0.08%.

Australian group evfiresafe retains an ongoing tally of fires in electrical automobiles. As of June 30, it has verified 393 battery fires globally since 2010.

The Takeaway

A number of weeks in the past, a neighbor despatched me an e mail a couple of horrible fireplace that supposedly occurred in an electrical automobile. It was throughout social media, because the pundits performed a sport of “Ain’t It Terrible.” There was a lot hand-wringing and moaning about how harmful electrical automobiles will be. Upon additional evaluation, nevertheless, the hearth truly befell in Russia and concerned a truck carrying propane tanks.

The ensuing fireplace was intense — and scary — however it had nothing in any way to do with electrical automobiles. I despatched him some details about how there are practically 200 gasoline fires involving vehicles within the US daily. I didn’t hear something again from him.

Because the information media continues to report exaggerated tales about fires in electrical automobiles, we take into account it our obligation to clap again with the reality. As at all times, ignorance will be overcome by the appliance of related info. There isn’t a recognized treatment for stupidity.


I do not like paywalls. You do not like paywalls. Who likes paywalls? Right here at CleanTechnica, we carried out a restricted paywall for some time, however it at all times felt mistaken — and it was at all times powerful to resolve what we should always put behind there. In concept, your most unique and greatest content material goes behind a paywall. However then fewer individuals learn it! We simply do not like paywalls, and so we have determined to ditch ours.

Sadly, the media enterprise remains to be a tricky, cut-throat enterprise with tiny margins. It is a endless Olympic problem to remain above water and even maybe — gasp — develop. So …