Inside The Netherlands’ Daring Vitality Future: Classes From TenneT & Past

---

Assist CleanTechnica’s work by means of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

---

On the finish of my engagement with TenneT, the Netherlands’ transmission system operator, who I assisted with 2050 situation planning for his or her goal grid, I had the chance to sit down down with a few members of the workshops to debate our findings. What follows is a flippantly edited transcript of the primary half of our dialog.

I’d like so as to add a particular due to Johnny Nijenhuis of Nijenhuis Trucking Options within the Netherlands, who volunteered his podcast studio, mics, and sound modifying for this.

Michael Barnard [MB]: Hello, welcome again to Redefining Vitality–Tech. I’m your host, Michael Barnard. I’ve bought a particular version from the Netherlands right now. My visitors are Paul Martin, a returning good friend of the podcast collection who wants no introduction, and Emiel van Druten, an worker of TenneT and the explanation Paul and I are right here within the Netherlands. Welcome, Paul and Emiel.

Emiel van Druten [EVD]: Good day. Good day. 

[MB]: So why don’t we begin with you, Paul. Give the ten-second model of your self because you’re already well-known. 

Paul Martin [PM]: Positive. I’m a chemical engineer, generally known as a skeptic of hydrogen and artificial molecules. I’ve labored in chemical expertise growth my whole profession. 

[MB]: And Emiel, you’re new right here and comparatively new to podcasting. I feel that is solely your second time, so no less than you’re not an entire newbie. Inform us a bit about your self and the way you ended up at TenneT, and ready to ask Paul and me, as Canadians, to fly hundreds of kilometers to return and assist you. 

[EVD]: Sure. What I do at TenneT is develop future power system eventualities with my colleagues. As a TSO [transmission system operator], we use these to stay up for 2030 and 2050 and ask, what’s going to the power system appear to be? Then we run grid calculations to see the place the bottlenecks shall be and the place we have to spend money on the grid. That’s my job, and we don’t do it alone. We work along with the opposite community operators within the Netherlands, the fuel TSO, and the regional DSOs [distribution system operator]. Each two years we create new eventualities, and we use these to information our funding plan, which appears 15 years into the longer term. 

Presently, we’re looking forward to 2040 with a goal grid, and even additional to 2050, to stipulate a blueprint for the longer term grid we could must construct. On the very least, we are able to start making ready for it. On this context, I invited you each as specialists to overview our eventualities and ask: do they make sense? Do they make financial sense? We wish to put together for a extremely electrified situation. Is our model of “most electrified” real looking, or is your greatest guess even greater? That’s why we spent final week collectively in a four-day, fairly intense however pleasurable workshop. We’ll speak extra about that right now. However first, let me clarify how I ended up on this place.

I began at TU Delft, the place I did a bachelor’s in mechanical engineering, then shifted to civil engineering and accomplished a grasp’s in hydraulic engineering. You may marvel: how does a “mechanical water man” find yourself engaged on power programs at a TSO? That path began with my grasp’s thesis. I did an internship at an engineering and consulting agency, and I requested if I might work on one thing on the boundary of water and power. They stated, nicely, for the reason that Netherlands is usually beneath sea degree, rainwater needs to be pumped out by means of pumping stations. A lot of these stations are on the finish of life and due for renovation. So, my thesis challenge grew to become designing a very good renovation technique for considered one of these stations.

I did a case examine on a web site with three one-megawatt pumps. On the time, it ran on fuel and diesel engines, however it was being electrified. That grew to become my thesis focus. We truly revisited that very pumping station with you right now. That have launched me to power. I spotted these stations might function when electrical energy costs had been low and when wind was ample, which drew me into the topic. The corporate the place I did my thesis requested if I needed to work in power transition as a result of they thought I had a ardour for it. I stated sure.

I labored there for seven years on the consultancy agency Witteveen+Bos, doing initiatives on pumping stations and offshore wind. For instance, I labored on the wind farm we drove previous, calculating what would occur if a turbine blade broke off and the way that may have an effect on dike security. 

[MB]: It was a really Dutch dialog, as a result of the query wasn’t whether or not a wind turbine blade may hit an individual or a cow, however somewhat: what if it hits the dike? What occurs to the dike? 

[EVD]: I used to be additionally calculating what would occur if a blade hit one of many high-voltage energy traces. The chance I got here up with was as soon as in a few million years, which was above the brink of as soon as in a billion years. So I needed to contact the TSO, TenneT—the place I now work—and ask in the event that they had been keen to simply accept that danger.

I did that type of work for seven years, throughout all kinds of initiatives. I labored on the constructed setting, serving to municipalities develop methods to get off pure fuel and electrify households. I labored on initiatives for ministries, throughout completely different sectors. Over time, I spotted I used to be at all times optimizing particular consumer issues, however I needed to step again and optimize the entire system from the next degree. That pushed me to search for new alternatives.

I additionally began a part-time PhD alongside my work. I did that for 4 years, however I found it’s very onerous to make actual progress part-time. I’ve one paper at present in overview on integrating wind, photo voltaic, and batteries behind a single grid connection, however once I had a toddler final yr, I spotted I used to be successfully juggling three jobs. That was simply an excessive amount of. I made a decision to put aside the PhD and later additionally switched jobs. Now I’m at TenneT, engaged on situation growth. It’s an excellent function, as a result of I get to have a look at all sectors and discover the place integration alternatives exist. 

[MB]: TenneT is the corporate that manages transmission for each the Netherlands and components of Germany, although in separate programs. Paul and I had been right here only for the Netherlands portion. It was an enchanting course of. And Paul, you had been nerding out as a lot as I used to be right now, as a result of Emiel organized a closing day journey for us. It was unimaginable—we noticed 200 megawatts of wind, 100 megawatts of photo voltaic, and sooner or later there shall be one other giant block of batteries added. 

[PM]: An entire gigawatt hour of batteries in a single discipline. It’s very spectacular. 

[MB]: From the place we had been standing, we might see a gigawatt of technology multi functional place. It was a number of corporations working in the identical space. Probably the most spectacular half was standing on the base of a wind turbine, contained in the turbine, searching at photo voltaic panels—and realizing it was all beneath sea degree. 

[EVD]: 5 meters. 

[MB]: So Paul, what was probably the most fascinating takeaway for you from right now? 

[PM]: I used to be beaming, smiling from ear to ear, as a result of it’s so clearly the longer term. We had been taking a look at what the way forward for world power will appear to be, and imagining that it took eight or 9 years to place collectively. The size of it’s spectacular. The native persons are engaged, concerned, and important part-owners of the challenge. After all, I loved the technical particulars too, however it was actually the sense that we had been trying straight on the future. It was very spectacular. 

[MB]: Having handled a number of the social aspect of wind power up to now, and with each Paul and me having robust ties to Ontario—me being an Ontario boy and nonetheless contemplating Toronto considered one of my dwelling cities, and Paul residing in Ontario and having a farm—we all know how completely different the social acceptance is right here. They’ve managed the social facet of wind power a lot better. Sure, they’re operating into issues now with new wind initiatives dealing with blockages, however the farmers personal an enormous share of this gigawatt of wind and photo voltaic. Even with restrictions and setbacks, they’re benefiting instantly.

After we had been speaking in regards to the piles being pushed in—50 by 50 centimeter angled piles—the hammering should have been heard for miles round. However for the farmers closest by, what they had been actually listening to was the sound of cash. 

[PM]: No one was feeling unhealthy or claiming their well being was negatively affected by this type of challenge. It’s simply one other crop popping out of the identical discipline. What’s to not like? 

[MB]: And randomly, that is the primary time I’ve ever been inside a wind turbine. 

[PM]: Me too. 

[MB]: I used to be stunned. Emiel, had you been inside a wind turbine that scale earlier than? 

[EVD]: No, not at this scale. I’m additionally a member of a citizen growth collective referred to as Windville, and I’ve been inside considered one of their generators. However that was fairly small in comparison with this one right here. This one was seven and a half megawatts. I went inside, and there have been a number of containers with the transformers. You might stack three transport containers aspect by aspect, two rows excessive, and it will all match inside. 

[MB]: The bottom was 14.5 meters throughout. It was a concrete mast, shipped in segments and assembled on web site, standing 130 meters excessive. Seven and a half megawatts from a single turbine. It was beautiful—the largest I’ve seen. 

[EVD]: On land. 

[MB]: Yeah, your entire row was of the biggest wind generators working on land. So thanks, Emiel, for organizing that. 

[PM]: What impressed me most was {that a} single turbine might energy seven and a half of the polder dike discharge pumps we noticed on the pumping station.

[EVD]: Sure, however to be clear—we weren’t simply wherever within the Netherlands. We had been in a spot that was the underside of the ocean. This a part of the Zuiderzee, the southern sea, was as soon as open water. After a serious flood, the Dutch determined to take measures. They constructed the Afsluitdijk on the northern finish of the Netherlands, tens of kilometers lengthy, to shut off the ocean. It grew to become an inland lake, the IJsselmeer, fed by the river IJssel. What was as soon as saltwater become freshwater.

After that, they requested: what subsequent? The reply was to construct a wholly new province on the underside of the lake by setting up a hoop dike. With the dike in place and pumping stations put in, they drained the water. The pumping station we visited right now was one accomplished throughout World Struggle II. As soon as the land was drained, it was swampy at first, then dried out, and farmers moved in to determine productive agriculture on the fertile soil.

As we speak, that very same reclaimed land is dwelling to among the greatest examples of farmer-led renewable initiatives, with communities growing giant wind farms within the Flevopolder and the Noordoostpolder, the place we visited. 

[MB]: The pumping station for the dikes was fascinating too. There’s a 5-and-a-half-meter distinction in water degree. It makes use of three 1.2 megawatt pumps, and we had been fortunate sufficient to be there when considered one of them began up. 

[EVD]: It was good as a result of the operator, Albert, instructed us that since this yr they’ve had hourly power costs. He seemed on the market that morning and scheduled the pumping to begin at 11 o’clock. He stated they’ll automate the method subsequent yr, however for now he chooses the pumping hours every morning. I believed, that’s precisely what I suggested 9 years in the past in my thesis—it’s good to see they’re lastly doing it. 

[MB]: They’ve already saved €100,000 with the non-automated course of, so as soon as it’s totally optimized, the impression shall be fascinating. However that is typical of the Netherlands: they tackle large infrastructure initiatives, look to the longer term, make daring strikes—after which they invited Paul and me to assist with a kind of daring strikes.

To characterize it—and Paul and Emiel can appropriate me—there’s a nationwide power situation course of that produces 4 completely different eventualities. Some assume excessive electrification, some low. They used the PESTLE methodology, which appears at politics, economics, and different components, and constructed extremes into every situation to ensure all angles had been coated.

However the consequence was that the excessive electrification situation—the one most related to TenneT because the transmission operator, the one which implied the best transmission buildout and the hardest case for his or her workload—nonetheless had a number of irrational assumptions baked into it. 

[EVD]: Sure, precisely—due to the tactic. When you have an uncertainty with a 5% likelihood of 1 consequence and a 95% likelihood of one other, the tactic nonetheless requires you to incorporate each in a situation. That works for explorative eventualities, however for the goal grid we wish a single image of 2050 after which work backward. From that, we ask: what does this imply for our system? When do we have to begin particular initiatives, and what can we start making ready now? For that, you desire a seemingly situation, not one constructed round outcomes you suppose are most unlikely.

That’s one of many causes we requested you to hitch us for the workshop. We needed you to take this situation and supply an financial sensitivity examine—an financial actuality examine, actually. We additionally needed to know if our “highest electrification” situation was consistent with your greatest guess, or in case your expectations had been greater. Business is particularly vital on this context. We do get complaints, particularly in regards to the extremely electrified eventualities, as a result of they assume a really giant industrial base. The Netherlands does have a disproportionately large business for such a small nation: 5 refineries, a big chemical sector, fertilizer manufacturing—all of it made attainable due to low cost Groningen fuel.

However that benefit is gone now, since we closed the Groningen discipline as a consequence of earthquakes. We do have the North Sea for offshore wind, however does that imply we are able to preserve all our present business and stay aggressive? That was the actual query we needed you to handle. On this situation, the place all the pieces from uncooked materials to remaining product is stored within the Netherlands and hydrogen is used closely in all processes, is that financial? Or is there one other, extra real looking path? That was my query to you.

[MB]: For me, one of many shocking issues in regards to the Netherlands was realizing that in some ways it serves because the refinery for Europe. Crude oil comes into the large ports, flows into the 5 main refineries, after which about 70% of the output transits the nation and goes on into Europe. 

[EVD]: We even export completed merchandise like lubricants again to America—the identical place the oil initially got here from. 

[MB]: That’s clearly an business in transition. Paul, what stunned you in regards to the Netherlands’ business—the issues that stood out as large or sudden, those that made you suppose, “Huh, that’s odd”? 

[PM]: Nicely, I don’t suppose I used to be stunned by industries being there. I used to be stunned by the truth that they had been nonetheless within the eventualities that had been evaluating for the explanations that Emiel has talked about and that we wanted to type of surgically take away them in an effort to ensure that we ended up with a, a view of the longer term that’s internally constant, you already know. You understand, to provide you an instance, about between 15 and 25% of each barrel of oil will get become one thing that’s not going to be burned at its finish of life. Nicely, you’ll be able to’t clearly keep an business that produces the opposite 75 to 85% of the barrel and sells it to someone else to burn in a future the place you’re not burning something that’s simply inconsistent. 

And in order a consequence we needed to go in and say, nicely yeah, you might have sustaining this business in right here. What you actually should be contemplating is sustaining the chemical substances and supplies portion, the smaller fraction of that and having a world dominant business place in that space that’s going to persist in a decarbonized future whereas the gasoline burning portion of it isn’t. So yeah, anyway, that’s the form of factor that had been introduced in to supply recommendation about. And I assume the opposite factor to say is it wasn’t simply Michael and myself. You understand, there have been different specialists that had been introduced in. 

Particularly Dr. Helene de Coninck. I’d been studying her group’s papers for a while and never realizing it was her. However, however yeah, she was a part of the method. And we additionally had Reinier Grimbergen. 

[MB]: Emiel, might you give us a fast potted bio of Helene? She’s completed an unlimited quantity in her profession. 

[EVD]: Oh sure. Helene was truly my co-supervisor for my PhD on the Technical College in Eindhoven, the place she’s a professor centered on programs in transition. She’s additionally an IPCC writer—she was one of many lead authors on the 1.5-degree report. She serves on the federal government’s scientific council and is concerned in lots of skilled teams on the power transition. She’s actually a key skilled within the Netherlands.

[MB]: Sure, and I actually revered her ethical compass, as a result of she held our toes to the hearth on unfavourable emissions—not simply attending to zero. 

[EVD]: Then there was Reinier Grimbergen. We invited him on the day we centered on business and transport fuels. Paul is clearly an business skilled, however Dutch business is so specific in its construction that we thought it will be invaluable to additionally usher in a Dutch business skilled who is aware of the panorama and the prevailing concerns. Reinier is a non-public advisor with an organization referred to as Science to Innovate, the place he helps companies check new concepts and improvements. He’s additionally a part of a startup growing a brand new course of to deliver to the Netherlands: methanol to olefins. Olefins are key in chemistry, and his course of can work with imported methanol or methanol created from plastic waste and residual waste streams.

That’s why we introduced him in. Within the situation course of we run with Netbeheer Nederland, we maintain stakeholder classes and invite present industries and their representatives. They typically say, “We don’t like these modifications, we’d favor to see the refinery sector stay bigger.” Generally that results in changes within the eventualities. We additionally create storylines and go to the actually large corporations, asking, “On this world, what would you do?” They reply with how they’d decarbonize, and we incorporate that into the eventualities. However new industries and rising applied sciences are underrepresented in that course of. That’s why we invited Reinier, and he made an excellent contribution. 

[MB]: One other section that stunned me with its sheer scale was the greenhouse business. Within the unique situation, the plan was to close down the two.5 gigawatts of mixed warmth and energy engines that present warmth, electrical energy, and carbon dioxide to the greenhouses—about 5 million tons of CO2 a yr to reinforce rising situations. As we labored by means of this, one of many clear factors Paul and I agreed on was to maintain all of that technology as capability. Then you’ll be able to energy it with secure sources and use it flexibly—simply as Paul does with the generator on his farm. 

[PM]: The vital factor a couple of backup energy gadget is that it meets two standards: it needs to be dependable, and it needs to be low cost. The capital price should be low. It doesn’t should be environment friendly, and it doesn’t essentially must have low emissions, as a result of by definition it gained’t be used fairly often. However it does should be cheap to maintain round. And what’s cheaper than gear that already exists, is headed for the scrap heap, and solely wants upkeep? Why wouldn’t you retain that capability?

One other fascinating level was the Netherlands’ potential to generate methane from biogenic sources—by means of anaerobic digestion of various feedstocks, and from correctly processing agricultural waste that may in any other case emit methane into the ambiance and worsen world warming. The potential there’s fairly important. Primarily, it’s about redeploying a useful resource that has been used within the mistaken method and turning it into one thing helpful—as saved gasoline. 

[EVD]: Lately, the road of considering within the Netherlands—and in a lot of the eventualities we developed in earlier rounds—was that everyone needed inexperienced methane. 

[PM]: All of them need it as a result of it’s acquainted, however not essentially due to the value. We wish to burn it—however we wish to burn it the proper method. 

[MB]: We additionally need it as an industrial feedstock, and we wish to burn it often. 

[EVD]: Sure, it had been deliberate for the constructed setting. The Netherlands is kind of centered on hybrid warmth pumps—putting in a warmth pump however holding a fuel backup boiler for when it will get too chilly. If that backup runs on inexperienced fuel, then it’s carbon impartial. That’s a serious a part of the technique. 

[MB]: We put a kibosh on that one fairly shortly. 

[EVD]: One other instance is the transport sector, the place LNG is used as a gasoline, with the thought of switching to inexperienced LNG. However you each stated, no—simply electrify that. Plus, LNG engines have the issue of methane slip, and methane continues to be a greenhouse fuel. 

[PM]: There are numerous locations on this planet that aren’t fascinated with taking that half step to methane, whether or not it’s biogenic or not. They don’t wish to cope with the greenhouse fuel implications from leakage, venting, and engine slip. So why tie your self to that path when there are different useful makes use of that don’t undergo from those self same downsides? 

[EVD]: What we discovered is that in the event you take away all of the inexperienced methane use from the constructed setting and transport, you release fairly a bit that may be redirected to business. We’ll get to that later. However it could possibly additionally function a backup gasoline for actually chilly durations—the everyday Dunkelflaute, lasting just a few days to 2 weeks in winter, when it’s chilly, cloudy, and windless. In these instances, wind and photo voltaic aren’t producing, and batteries are drained after half a day.

So it made probably the most sense to maintain the prevailing methane vegetation and the mixed warmth and energy vegetation within the greenhouses and run them throughout these hours. We had sufficient inexperienced fuel to cowl that. The present image within the Netherlands, nevertheless, assumes all of that shall be hydrogen energy vegetation, both transformed or newly constructed. 

[MB]: And anybody who’s listened to Paul or me will know we shut down the thought of hydrogen for power fairly shortly. 

[PM]: That bought a fork in its rear finish fairly quick. 

[MB]: Sure, there’s a transparent thread right here. Proper now, our biomass waste streams are large sources of anthropogenic methane, which is a serious world warming drawback. The method we’re pointing to is regionalized biodigesters that seize and produce biomethane, stopping the methane emissions Paul talked about. What’s left are vitamins like potassium and phosphorus, which will be returned to the soil. 

[PM]: Again to the fields—and in lots of circumstances a very good portion of the nitrogen too, relying on the biomass supply. You recuperate a lot of the nutritive worth for fertilizer use that method. And on high of that, you’re getting power. What’s to not like? 

[MB]: Paul and I’ve been bullish for years on this: if you have already got a strategic pure fuel reserve and infrastructure that burns pure fuel, then put biomethane into that reserve. That turns into your Dunkelflaute retailer—as a result of the system already exists. 

[PM]: As I stated earlier than, backup energy units run very occasionally by definition. You don’t wish to spend a lot capital on them—you wish to preserve prices as little as attainable. So retailer a yr’s price of biomethane within the present infrastructure. Assist these services, possibly even nationalize among the property if mandatory, since they’ll be used so not often that they change into extra like strategic reserves. They exist for societal resilience towards emergencies, which business typically struggles to fund by itself. Or maybe it might be supported by means of some type of capability market. 

[EVD]: Sure, there are completely different ranges to this. At TenneT, my group can be accountable for the adequacy outlook, the place we glance forward and ask whether or not we’ll be tight on producing capability throughout these chilly weeks. We sign to the ministry if we count on shortfalls within the coming years—towards 2030 and 2035. The ministry is now contemplating whether or not motion is required, and whether or not capability mechanisms or capability markets might be sure that property that are not economically viable nonetheless stay obtainable as backup. 

[MB]: And the identical factor applies to Dunkelflaute. Paul and I stored having this recurring expertise over the previous week—taking a look at one another and saying, wow, are we ever envious as Canadians. 

[PM]: For positive. The Netherlands is thus far forward in some ways. In Canada, we now have super pure benefits, however for one motive or one other we don’t appear very wanting to benefit from them. Within the Netherlands, it’s the other. The nation is bodily small and constrained in methods Canada isn’t, but they’re a lot additional forward on decarbonization general—though they began from a harder place, being actually underwater. 

[MB]: On that notice, one space the place they’re far forward of just about your entire world is seasonal thermal power storage. Emiel, didn’t you design one thing in that house as soon as? 

[EVD]: Sure, that was the type of challenge we labored on on the engineering firm—growing aquifer thermal power storage. 

[MB]: Why don’t you describe that? Individuals outdoors the Netherlands typically don’t know what it’s. 

[EVD]: In the event you go into the subsurface at 100 or a pair hundred meters, you discover sand layers. When these sand layers are sandwiched between impermeable clay layers, that’s best, as a result of you’ll be able to pump water out and in with out dropping it. You drill two wells: one for extraction and one for injection. You pull up water from the extraction nicely—it’s not sizzling, however round 20 levels—and in winter you should utilize a warmth pump to improve it to about 40 levels to heat a constructing. The cooled water is then reinjected into the opposite nicely, creating a chilly retailer. In summer season, you reverse the system: you deliver up the chilly water to chill buildings, which is particularly invaluable for business buildings with giant cooling wants.

The warmth from summer season is saved underground and introduced again up in winter. It’s primarily a seasonal balancing mechanism. Greenhouses use this too, since they’ve surplus warmth in summer season from daylight. By storing it underground, they will use it in winter. The Netherlands already has hundreds of those aquifer thermal storage programs in operation, and we’re persevering with to scale them up. The greenhouse sector particularly is adopting them broadly. Previously, greenhouses relied on mixed warmth and energy vegetation for baseload warmth. Now these vegetation will be retained as backup for when it’s very chilly and electrical energy costs are excessive.

The great thing about the system is that in the event you swap on the CHP in these situations, it could possibly provide electrical energy for the warmth pump, which is the baseload supply, so that you don’t have to purchase costly grid energy. Any extra waste warmth from the CHP additionally goes straight into the greenhouse. It’s a very elegant instance of system integration. 

[MB]: Sure, and the Netherlands has a few important benefits with aquifer thermal power storage. One is that there are many sand layers, for the reason that nation sits on a mixture of sandstone and shale. 

[EVD]: It’s truly simply unfastened sand, not stone. 

[MB]: Good level. The second benefit is that the Netherlands has deep experience in directional drilling from its oil and fuel business. They know tips on how to steer drills horizontally underground, and never each nation has that functionality in its company base. Which means if an aquifer is offset a kilometer or two to the aspect, they will nonetheless attain it. However then the Delta T turns into vital. Paul, do you wish to dive into the nerdy particulars of Delta T and the way this thermal storage works? 

[PM]: Within the unique situation we reviewed, there have been a number of hybrid warmth pumps. To provide an instance, in a spot like Alberta in Canada, winters are so chilly that the coefficient of efficiency—the ratio of warmth a pump delivers to the electrical energy it consumes—drops considerably. It will get to the purpose the place you may as nicely use resistance heating.

The Netherlands, although, has a way more reasonable local weather. So we had been stunned to see hybrid warmth pumps there—programs that truly burn gasoline to supply warmth for the pump through the coldest days. Given the local weather, it appeared pointless.

This ties again to the Delta T Michael talked about—the distinction between the chilly supply you’re drawing warmth from and the new house you’re pumping it into. That temperature raise is the work the system has to do, and it drives the effectivity. Within the Netherlands, the Delta T is small, and with aquifer seasonal storage offering surprisingly environment friendly warmth retention from summer season to winter, the required raise could be very modest. Which means coefficients of efficiency are exceptionally good, which makes your entire system rather more smart. 

[EVD]: Sure, however it solely works when you have district heating. It’s a large-scale challenge—you don’t construct it for 100 households. You want a number of hundred properties plus some business buildings to make it viable. District heating is nice as a result of it permits system integration with a number of sources: you’ll be able to have a baseload supply, a power-to-heat boiler that kicks in when electrical energy costs are zero or unfavourable, and a backup possibility. That’s not possible on the single-household degree, as a result of sustaining three programs for one dwelling doesn’t make financial sense.

That ties to what you identified about hybrid warmth pumps. Having two programs in particular person properties, and holding the fuel distribution community alive simply so households can use just a few hundred cubic meters of fuel a yr, merely doesn’t work. Ultimately, the fastened prices of the fuel connection make every cubic meter extraordinarily costly. That creates a robust incentive to remove these previous couple of hundred cubic meters, even when it means counting on electrical heating. It’s higher to design a correct warmth pump from the beginning and go all-electric, as a substitute of including a hybrid system after which later attempting to section out the fuel aspect. That was our conclusion.

One other odd focus we noticed within the Netherlands is within the authorities cost-effectiveness fashions. They put an excessive amount of emphasis on cloth effectivity—insulation. They assume that you must retrofit buildings to close new-build requirements earlier than putting in an all-electric warmth pump. 

[MB]: To qualify for a grant for an all-electric warmth pump, they added a requirement that you simply first meet excessive insulation requirements—a failure widespread in lots of governance and regulatory programs. 

[EVD]: I’m unsure if it’s a subsidy requirement, however the mannequin assumes you can solely swap to all-electric or low-temperature district heating if your private home has no less than a label B power ranking. In the event you’re at label D or simply reasonably insulated, the mannequin suggests it gained’t work. However in apply, with good design and by optimizing the warmth change system—like including ventilators to radiators—you can also make it work.

My own residence runs on an all-electric warmth pump with solely radiators, no ground heating. I added ventilators, and I obtain a COP of three and a half to 4. My home is pretty nicely insulated, however there are many different examples, with metering knowledge, exhibiting you may get strong efficiency from an all-electric system even in older homes. 

[MB]: Oh sure. And as I perceive it, the mannequin assumed it will price round €100,000 in cloth upgrades to deliver the common home as much as top-grade requirements.

[EVD]: Sure, no less than one thing like €30,000. That’s evaluating apples and pears. In the event you power all-electric programs to hold the burden of very costly, non–cost-optimal insulation, whereas hybrid warmth pumps solely want minimal upgrades, the comparability is skewed. With simply modest, cost-effective insulation, you can also make all-electric work. That’s why I need the mannequin modified to permit label D properties to go all-electric.

They did run a sensitivity evaluation, although, assuming all homes had been upgraded to close new-build, label B normal. Once they re-ran the fee optimization underneath that assumption, virtually no hybrids had been deployed, and there was little or no district heating. If buildings are so nicely insulated that they want only a few gigajoules per sq. meter, the excessive price of district heating pipes doesn’t pencil out. The consequence was 80–85% all-electric particular person warmth pumps. That’s what we selected to incorporate within the situation: remove the final 10% of hybrids, transfer to roughly 80% all-electric particular person options, and round 15% district heating. It might be optimum to lift district heating to twenty%, however socially it’s tough.

Within the Netherlands, each family has to enroll in district heating, and also you want no less than 90% participation to make the enterprise case work. That requires native ambassadors to persuade neighbors, however the individuals most definitely to be ambassadors are the early adopters of all-electric warmth pumps—who’ve already solved their very own drawback. So, in apply, solely the neighborhoods formally designated by municipalities as future district heating zones, with clear communication to residents, have a robust likelihood of success. Elsewhere, it’s a really onerous promote to get sufficient individuals to enroll. 

[MB]: One of many issues I’ve noticed is that the Netherlands is a sufferer of its personal success in some areas. With district heating, for instance, I’ve pointed to regulating fuel distribution utilities to change into heat-as-a-service suppliers. Corporations like Vattenfall and Ennatuurlijk had been already doing that. However they had been gouging clients on the fee per BTU of warmth, which upset lots of people. Now municipalities are pulling that accountability again and saying, “We don’t need you concerned—we’ll do it ourselves.” 

[EVD]: The quick model is that this: heating is regulated, and the rule is that district heating service shouldn’t price greater than what a family would have paid with a fuel boiler—the “no more costly than earlier than” precept. However within the calculation, they embody an costly upkeep contract and a expensive boiler. Because of this, the tariff finally ends up greater than what many individuals truly paid earlier than. Add within the excessive fastened charges, and persons are understandably aggravated. That’s created a number of unfavourable sentiment.

They’ve been engaged on revising the regulation for collective warmth—what we name district heating—for a number of years now, however it’s gone backwards and forwards. Municipalities are more and more saying they need to personal and function the programs themselves, and the method is transferring in that course. However the delays are piling up. Within the meantime, warmth pumps preserve getting put in, and the very individuals who might need been ambassadors for district heating are as a substitute changing into adopters of warmth pumps.